"Campaign for autonomy of temples, pluralism and development"

 
     
 

Letter to Shri Ashok Singhal ji, President Vishwa Hindu Parishad

Subject: The urgency of repulsing the Assault on Hinduism & Hindu religious infrastructure under a predatory anti-Hindu environment:  

Aadarniya Shri Singhal ji,

We are sending this urgent memo in the hope that you and the rest of the top Hindu leadership will give serious consideration to some of the important issues mentioned here facing the Hindu Samaj in the forthcoming Tritya Vishwa Hindu Sammelan being held at Prayag during February 11-13, 2007. 

It is grievously disturbing to Hindus that despite being over 80% of the national population they are contemptuously neglected by the present political establishment while the minorities are bestowed upon unconstitutional special favors in the prevalent environment of vote- bank politics. The Govt. control of temples is being used as the central instrument of attack on temples and the poisonous caste based politics has been made the key to tear the Hindu infrastructure apart. The current governments, at the centre and states, are purposely weakening the majority and blatantly appeasing and encouraging Muslim separatism by following a colonial policy of divide and rule. They show least concern about the disastrous consequences of this upside down policy.

Some of the recent developments have compelled us to approach and draw your kind attention to this highly disturbing problem. They include: a) The appointment by the Kerala HC of a three man committee to investigate corruption charges against the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB), followed by the Leftist Front government in Kerala issuing an ordinance scrapping the 56-year-old Travancore-Cochin Devaswom; b) the contentious dredging work on the sacred Sethu Bridge; and, c) the judgment by the Orissa HC upholding the right of the Dalits to enter temples. Accordingly we humbly suggest that the issues stated hereunder be seriously deliberated upon during the forthcoming Hindu Leaders conference at the Prayag. 

1)  The transfer of the management, governance and administration of temples in Kerala to the Hindu community;

2) Exoneration of the Kanchi Shankaracharya against the false and fabricated charges; 

3) Cancellation of Sethusamudram project to save the historic monument so very sacred to Hindus;

4)  Amendment of Article 30 of the Constitution to enable Hindu NGOs spread education amongst masses; 

5) Utilizing the Orissa HC verdict on entry in to temples by Dalits so as to integrate them with the rest of the Hindu Samaj and thereby preempt the campaign for conversion by competing religionists.

***A) It is no secret that the Kerala Govt. has assumed total control of the Hindu temples in the state and completely undermined the fundamental right of the Hindu community to manage and govern these entities without the interference of the state. To advance its anti-Hindu strategy lately it has Scrapped off the Travancore-Cochin Devaswom Act. While the Kerala HC recently appointed a 3 man committee to investigate graft charges against the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB), the Kerala Govt. on the other hand promulgated an ordinance scrapping the 56-year-old Travancore-Cochin Devaswom Act. The enforcement of this ordinance in particular represents an attempt to curtail for obvious reasons the powers of the officially created Travancore and Cochin Devaswom Boards charged with the responsibility of managing most of the temples in the state. (Attachments A1 and A2).

Taking note of these developments the Hindus across Kerala and beyond are indignant about the recent pronouncement by the Marxist Govt. to take over Hindu Temples and issue ordinances apparently to loot funds of the Hindu temple. Many of the Marxist plans are intended to substantially curtail Hindu religious practices, restrict and downsize the traditional cultural festivals and thereby detach and distance the worshipers from the Hindu cultural centers with a view to soften them for proselytizers (attachment A3).

It is believed that the Marxist Govt. may be contemplating to grab temple lands, gold deposits and funds for usage to promote its own ideological and institutional goals. In Kerala, the majority of Hindu temples are already controlled by the Govt. However, the Muslims and Christians are free to manage their mosques and churches, run their schools, and manage their funds and properties without Govt. interference or supervision. They even finance subversive schemes like conversion activities, preach a litany of hate and turn out thousands of fanatic zealots, yet the Govt. does not show any concern about such disruptive behavior. 

The autonomy of the Nationalized Hindu religious institutions must be restored and they be transferred to Hindu Board for governance. The Kerala Govt. must be warned that: a) The Karnataka High Court has struck down the Karnataka Hindu Religious Institutions and Charitable Endowment Act, 1997 as unconstitutional pointing out that its provisions amounted to “dividing Hindu religion.”; and b) The Allahabad High Court has directed the Central and UP authorities to prepare a scheme for constituting a Board for Hindu religious organizations on the pattern of the UP Muslim Waqf Board. The Kerala authorities by no means can escape the legal and constitutional implications of these historic verdicts by the premier judicial authorities.

Furthermore the Indian Parliament through an Act in 1991 legislated that –“the status of religious places, as on August 15, 1947 shall be retained". The faithful implementation of this law itself will require the authorities to respect and maintain the autonomous status of the Hindu places of worship.

In order to abide by the constitutional and legal provisions the Kerala Govt. must denationalize temples and restore their jurisdiction to the Hindu community. Such a transformation would be legal, pragmatic, non controversial and will be in keeping with the high ideals of secularism and democracy. Here are some of the measures that should be taken by the state during the transitional period to safeguard the Hindu infrastructure while denationalization is underway:

a) Declare a time table for ending Govt. control of Temples and for transferring their jurisdiction in its entirety to an Autonomous Hindu board;
b) Make the endowments department transparent and open to public scrutiny with immediate effect;
c) freeze all plans and actions in the domain of temples except for their routine maintenance, pujaris salaries, temple rituals, etc. ;
d) End unconstitutional taxation of temples and diversion of their revenues right away; and
e)  Set up a Hindu Council, nominated by Hindu organizations like Dharma Sansad and Hindu Dharma Acharya Sabha to prevent anti- Hindu management and oversight and constructive guidance of endowment departments till denationalization is realized.  

***B) The unconditional exoneration of Kanchi Shankaracharya; the Hindu world is deeply anguished by the continued incarceration of His Holiness, who in spite of the false charges against him, continues to command respectability and reverence better than the Catholic Pope. Therefore, in the interest of social harmony, justice and respect for millions of his followers all efforts must be made to see that charges and the case against him is withdrawn. That the TN Govt. has had over two years to furnish credible evidence in support of its case against the saint yet it miserably failed to do so. The failure of the authorities itself should have been enough to conclude that the case was a malicious and a fabricated one intended to hurt Hinduism by falsely implicating its highest religious leader.

The following grounds establish without a doubt that in this imbroglio the central underlying motive was a religio-political conspiracy: His Holiness has been:

i)                   A thorn in the flesh of evangelists, and he was furious on Jayalalitha’s withdrawal of the anti-conversion law following her rout in the Lok Sabha elections.

ii)                    Days before his arrest, he had also vehemently opposed the Endowments Act whereby government assumed the control over temples.

iii)                 He strongly supported the demand for the removal of non-believers and the agents of the competing religions from temple managements;

iv)                 He supported the use of temple finances for purely Hindu religious causes (i.e., funds from Hindu temples should not subsidize the Hajj and Church construction and maintenance).

The fulfillment of these demands would have spun the official erroneous policy out of the orbit and down the drain.

The Kanchi Shankaracharya is the foremost spiritual leader of the Hindu faith. Among the four mutts set up by Adi Shankaracharya, who is credited with reviving the Hindu religion in medieval India, the Kanchi Peeth is the most revered. Others include the Dwarka, Badrinath and Puri Peeth. The Shankaracharya was also in the news as his devotees include the who's who among the politicians and industrialists. President APJ Abdul Kalam was among the distinguished crowd.

We cannot sit idle hoping that "the Law will take its own course" when the Govt. takes up a partisan role, or the system gets so bogged down to effectively deny justice:  e.g. a) the Bombay blast cases of 1993 after the Babri demolition are still going on; b) the Bofors case that started in late eighties was going on till recently when the UPA Govt. finished it off by astute administrative moves. At this rate the Holy Seer may be dead or physically incapacitated by the time the case against him is deliberated - thus allowing complete demolition of a great Hindu institution by a partisan anti- Hindu establishment.

After a lapse of two years there are strong grounds to mount a public campaign against the TN Govt. compelling it to withdraw the case, because it has not been able to provide any credible proof in support of its accusations against the Hindu leader. As an alternative a request could be filed before the SC of India for dismissing the case in view of the state government’s outright failure to substantiate its charges.

***C) Recognizing its religious and historic character, the Sethu Bridge must be preserved: The bridge has been revered by the Hindus since time immemorial and has a great cultural, traditional and historical value. Even the AIADMK supreme, Jayalalithaa, has opposed the ongoing dredging in this area of Rama Sethu Bridge, stating that it was a historical monument therefore, must be maintained intact. A state court under the strictest partisan atmosphere understandably declined to provide the necessary relief against the ill-advised drudging. (Attachment B) 

Arrest of H.H. Kanchi Shankarachrya on cooked up charges and installation of the statue of E V Ramasamy Naicker - Periyar for the devotees of Dravidianism in front of the Rajagopuram of Srirangam temple with underhand support of Govt. in Tamil Nadu would give credence to the allegation that the objective of the Sethusamudram project is the denigration of Hinduism by attacking yet another of its historic icons.

Rama Sethu Bridge of the Ramayana times must be classified as religious, cultural, historical and an ancient monument of invaluable archaeological importance. Unlike many others this site has immense traditional and cultural value for the vast majority of Indian citizens. The Bridge has been revered by the entire Hindu civilization since times immemorial. The age-old belief existing around this historical monument was recently further validated as factual, true and real by the graphic satellite images.

It should be noted that Taj corridor scheme on the banks of river Yamuna, was barred by the Supreme Court on the ground that it would threaten the historic Taj Mahal; and the Delhi Metro Rail route was changed when the older scheme was considered dangerous to the historic Qutub Minar. Unless there are some hidden reasons the same sense of history, culture and preservation must be applied here.
 
Dredging work at the Sethu Bridge, which is a part of Ramayana and is deeply embedded in the Hindu psyche, hurts intense religious beliefs and sentiments while causing unavoidably heightened degrees of distress and deep resentment amongst a billion Hindus worldwide. If the ongoing destructive process is not stopped right away, not only will the historic character of the site render itself irreparably and fundamentally altered - but in future unavoidably there would be highly critical and unfavorable comments in every Ramayana Katha for generations, that there was a Congress regime that in utter violation of the sense and sensibility of the Indian people heartlessly destroyed the age old traditional and sacred Ram Sethu Bridge.
 

***D) The opportunities for spreading Education amongst the community and masses must not be denied to Hindus. For this purpose the Article 30 of the Indian Constitution needs to be amended. We strongly suggest that VHP spearhead a campaign to amend Article 30 of the Constitution for allowing the same benefits and freedom to the Hindu educational institutions as are provided to such entities belonging to the minority communities. This Article directly discriminates the majority community therefore, must be amended to make it non-discriminatory and universal. 

The existing  discriminatory intent of the Article seriously impedes the work of Hindu NGOs in the field of mass education, while the Madrasas with Jihadist outlook threatening the integrity of the nation thrive.  Furthermore, such discrimination forces some groups to prefer being out side the boundaries of Hinduism for gaining these benefits which in turn leads to fragmentation of the community. Ramakrishna Mission had argued on such lines, though the SC denied its request. Now the Jains are trying to use the same argument for gaining educational benefits.

Contrastingly the Christians and Muslims besides enjoying the official patronage receive massive foreign funds for many activities including running schools and Madrassas while the Hindus are handicapped by the inequitable laws.  Even their own religious infrastructure is not available to them for spreading the necessary education. The removal of the ongoing step motherly treatment will go a long way to alleviate the Hindu institutions and their functioning to the same level as the similar outfits of other religious formations in the country.

***E)  To realize the objective of the “integrated the Hindu Society” as a whole the judgment of the Orissa HC on the issue of the Dalit’s entry in to Hindu temples serves as a landmark verdict and it should be utilized to the fullest.  In this significant judgment, the Orissa High Court on December 5, 2006 ruled that Dalits have a right to enter any Hindu temple. This historic verdict opened the gates of the 300 year old shrine of Jagannath temple in Keredagada, Orissa for the Dalits. The caste Hindus, who heretofore had maintained a belligerent stand on this issue, finally agreed and recognized the right of the Dalits for worshipping in the temples and performing puja. (Attachment C).

This unprecedented court ruling in Orissa provides an invaluable opportunity to VHP workers for initiating social work amongst the Dalits like Gandhi ji which in turn could culminate into socio-political and religious rewards. For this extremely important task VHP may also have to launch and encourage building a dedicated cadre of volunteers with exemplary skills for goal oriented social service. The joint worship by the hitherto isolated segments of Hindus accompanied by economic and educational improvements, enacting laws against conversion and ending discrimination by amending the Article 30 of the constitution is bound to usher in a new environment of hope, unity and integration. In order to make up for the deficit of the media coverage - the Kathas, religious discourses and cultural festivals could be used for launching these initiatives.

We sincerely hope and believe that the top brass of the Hindu leadership in the country congregating at Prayag will find time and opportunity for giving serious consideration to these issues and come up with a new agenda for activism aiming at generating an enthusiastic movement with needed momentum and mass appeal for bringing about a new Hindu awakening.

With respectful pranams,

Dr. Jagan Kaul
Krishan Bhatnagar

Hindu Jagran Forum (USA)

February 07, 2007


Attachment A1

Hindu Press International: January 8, 2007

Top Kerala Temple Board Faces Graft Probe

www.gulf-times.com

KOCHI, INDIA, January 3, 2007: The Kerala High court yesterday set up a three-member committee to probe corruption charges against a board that runs many temples in the state. The committee led by former Supreme court judge K.S. Paripoornan with former Central Bureau of Investigation director D.R. Karthikeyan and former judge Tulasidas as members has been asked to submit a report on the case against the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB) within six months. The TDB manages and runs temples in the southern districts of Kerala, including the Sabarimala temple which is expected to net revenue of more than US$22 million in the ongoing festival season that closes on January 20. The autonomous temple authority also runs a number of schools, colleges and cultural institutions.

The TDB has been accused of misappropriating money donated by devotees, corruption in purchases and taking bribes while recruiting staff. The state's Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau had earlier submitted a report to the government on the irregularities in the TDB deals. The court said it was the court's duty to ensure that the money donated by the devotees is not misused or wasted and hence the order. While welcoming the court verdict, Temple Affairs Minister G. Sudharkaran said the government would soon issue an ordinance making amendments in the laws governing the three temple administration boards in the state


Attachment A2

Kerala Govt takes teeth out of Hindu temple body

http://www.ibnlive.com/news/kerala-takes-teeth-out-of-temple-body/top/32524-3.html?xml

Thiruvananthapuram: The Left Front government in Kerala has passed an ordinance scrapping the 56-year-old Travancore-Cochin Devaswom Act.

The ordinance is an attempt to curtail the powers of the Travancore and Cochin Devaswom boards, which manage most of the temples in Kerala.

The decision comes in the wake of allegations of corruption in the Travancore Devaswom Board, which governs the Sabarimala temple and earns about Rs 70 crore a year.

"Not only against this, action will be taken against the person involved in this. There were corruption charges against all boards, except the first and the second," says Kerala Minister for Devaswoms, G Sudakaran.

The three-member Devaswom board will now include one woman and one member from the SC/ST community.

The board's activities will also undergo judicial review from time to time. The government's move has obviously not gone down well with the board members who have reacted sharply to the issue.

The board has reacted sharply to the government's move.

"We will go to the court now to see that we get justice. The government says the board is corrupt. Even then what's the need for such an ordinance when you have a vigilance enquiry on and when already a judicial commission is also looking into the charges against the board," says a Travancore Devaswom Board member, Punalur Madhu.

By promulgating this ordinance, the government seems to have drawn the first blood in its battle against the Travancore Devaswom board.

But now the big question is: how far the government will keep away from the day-to-day activities of temples in Kerala, which otherwise will have serious implications?


Attachment A3

HAV protests Marxist game plan to loot Hindu temples
1/23/2007 12:12:55 PM  HK Correspondent

haindava keralam

Jan. 23,2007

Hinduworld.com

Hindus across Kerala are uneasy about the recent pronouncement of the Marxist government to take over Hindu Temples and ordinances to loot Hindu Temple funds. Many of the Marxist plans are intended to curtail temple practices, restrict traditional cultural festivals and to make Hindus easy for proselytizers.

The Marxist government is planning to grab temple lands, gold deposits and funds for their own ideological purposes. In Kerala, the majority of Hindu temples are controlled by the government. Muslims and Christians are free to manage their mosques and churches, can run their schools, and manage their funds and property without government interference. They finance conversion activities, preach a litany of hate and turn out thousands of fanatic zealots without any government interference. 

The Marxist plan of action against Hindu temples is an unacceptable challenge to Hindus. To raise Hindu awareness and to protest Marxist plans, Hindu Ayika Vedi have decided to have several Hindu conventions across Kerala. Temple devotees across Kerala will organize mass protest in different parts of Kerala. Kummanam Rajasekharan, General Secretary of Hindu Ayka Vedi has announced that temple devotees from Trichur district will meet at Paramakavu temple ground on January 25. Temple organizations and representatives from various Hindu Associations will meet at Tirunakara Mahadeva Temple, Kottayam on January 27. On February 1, Hindu leadership conference will be held at Thiruananthapuram. 

Kummanam Rajasekharan asked the Marxist government to refrain from their nefarious activities determined to destroy Hindu temples. He demanded an explanation and details on the ordinance the Marxist government and the 15 point formula of the Marxist Devasom Minister to take over Hindu temples. 

Hindu temple is the abode of GOD, the focus for all aspects in the life of Hindus—religious, spiritual, social, cultural and educational. It is a center where God can be approached and where divine knowledge can be discovered. All aspects of Hindu life and culture revolve around Hindu temples. It is time for Hindus to join together and correct this trend of Hindu temple looting.


Attachment B

1)  Another setback to Sethusamudram project work

Monday, 29 January , 2007, 13:09
Sifynews.com

Madurai: In yet another setback to the dredging work of Sethusamudram Ship Channel Project, a giant crane sent to retrieve the spud that broke while trying to cut the "Ramar Sethu" or Adams Bridge in the Palk Strait has also broken and a part of it had sunk in the sea, officials said.

The spud of the "Cutter-Sucker-Dredger Aquarius" had broken last week while cutting the bridge, dealing a blow to the dredging work. With the crane also broken, the project was likely to be delayed further, the officials said.

The 150-tonne floating tug crane "Thangam", hired for several lakh of rupees a day by the project officials, could not pull out the spud and broke in the process on Sunday.

The crane's locking-key had broken and it would take another 10 days to retrieve and repair it.
Officials were now thinking of bringing a bigger crane -Hanuman - having 200 tonne capacity from Visakhapatnam to retrieve both the sunken crane and the spud.

AIADMK supremo Jayalalithaa has opposed dredging in the area of Ramar Sethu bridge, stating that it was a historical monument.

According to Hindu mythology, Lord Ram constructed a stone bridge to enable his Vaanara Sena to cross the Palk Straits to wage war with Ravan, King of Lanka, who had abducted his wife Seetha.

http://sify.com/news/fullstory.php?id=14377459
 


2 ) Plea to stop 'damage' to Rama Sethu bridge
NT Bureau
News Today
Chennai, Jan 7: 

A Civil suit seeking to restrain the Union government from doing anything which would damage the Rama Sethu bridge of the Ramayana times in the Palk Straits has been filed in a sub court of Ramanathapuram district by Swami Omkarananda of Theni Sidbavananda Ashram and the Ramanathapuram district president of the RSS Kuppuramu. 

Hearing the suit on 5 January, the court issued notices to the Centre, Sethusamudram Corporation and Archeological Survey of India and posted the case for hearing on 12 January. Explanations have been sought whether the dredging work in progress for the Sethu Samudram project would damage the bridge of the epic age. 

When the suit came up for hearing, it was argued that the dredging work in the area where the ancient Ramar bridge was located would destroy the ancient symbol of link between India and Lanka. Hence the dredging work should be given up in the location. 

It was also said the bridge was revered by the Hindus since time immemorial and has a great traditional and historical value. 

When the Uttar Pradesh government wanted to go ahead with the Taj corridor scheme on the banks of river Yamuna, it was barred by the Supreme Court on the ground that it would threaten the historic Taj Mahal. Likewise, the Delhi Metro Rail route had to be changed when the older scheme was considered as dangerous to the Qutub Minar. 

Subsequently, notices were sent to the State and Central governments for their response. The case has been adjourned to 12 January. 

It may be noted that tradition has it that a bridge was constructed during the Ramayana period for war with Ravaneswaran by the forces of Sri Rama. 

The age-old belief was recently validated as true by the graphic satellite images of the premium American aeronautics and space research agency, NASA. The images released by it revealed an ancient bridge, which linked Rameswaram with Sri Lanka. The length of the bridge was found to be 30 km and the breadth 3 km. 

Meanwhile, the AIADMK supremo Jayalalithaa and some fishermen's associations have also been opposing the Sethusamudram Ship Channel Project (SSCP) saying that the project would destroy marine ecology in the Bay of Bengal and deprive the fishermen of their livelihood. 

The Rs 2400 crore project envisages dredging of a navigation lane in the shallow waters of the Palk Straits, enabling ships to move between eastern and western ports of the country without touching the Sri Lankan coast. 

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had laid the foundation for the project on 2 July, 2005


Attachment C

Dalits have right to enter Hindu temple: HC
Outlookindia.com

Hinduworld.com

CUTTACK, DEC 5 (PTI) : In a significant judgement, the Orissa High Court today ruled that Dalits have a right to enter any Hindu temple.

"Every Hindu, irrespective of his caste, has a right to enter any Hindu temple which is open to other persons professing the same religion," a division bench of Chief Justice Sujit Burman Roy and Justice M M Das observed.

The bench was hearing a PIL filed seeking protection for Dalits for their entry into the Jagannath temple at Keredagada in Kendrapara district.

The High Court's ruling came in the wake of a severe caste conflict brewing up among the Dalits and those belonging to the upper caste over the issue of entry of Dalits into the 300-year-old Hindu shrine.  The court also directed the Kendrapara district administration to take appropriate action provided under the law if any law and order situation arose at the temple site over the issue of entry into the place of worship.

The court had directed on November 24 last that the temple would remain out of bounds for all except the priests and sevayats of the shrine.

The direction had come after the district administration had moved the High Court seeking imposition of status quo over the question of entry into the shrine in view of the growing tension in the area.

A large number of Dalits, backed by the Ambedkar-Lohia Vichar Manch, had earlier threatened to forcibly enter the temple. They later had warned that they would stage a 'Satyagraha' outside the temple on November 26.

With the disposal of the petition, the interim direction of November 24 stood vacated.

Hearing a batch of intervening petitions along with the PIL, the court relied upon the provisions made under Article 17 of the Constitution, which prevented the practice of untouchability and the provisions of the protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955, while disposing off the case.

The Ambedkar-Lohia Vichar Manch, represented through its counsel Khirod Kumar Rout as an intervener, told the court that Section 3 of the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955 clearly stated that anybody practicing untouchability invited punishment under the law.

2) Orissa Dalits Gain Temple Access

Hindu Press International

HPI, January 28, 2007 

www.thestatesman.net

KENDRAPARA, ORISSSA, January 28, 2007: After weeks of discord and strife that had threatened civil order, the dispute over Dalits' rights to have darshan (view of the Deity) at the Jagannath temple in Keredagada was finally settled today with the lower caste Hindus marching their way to the 300-year-old shrine. "We are happy to know that people have buried the caste-based practices and peace and harmony have returned to Keredagada," Kendrapara collector Mr. Kashinath Sahu said. "It is a victory of law over tradition. We appreciate the gesture of upper caste Hindus for their tolerant attitude. The upper caste sabarnas no more hold the view that the darshan by the Dalits would desecrate the temple," said senior revenue officers who had rushed to Keredagada early morning today. ......

...There was a sharp divide on caste line in this part of the state after the Dalits broke the age-old social barriers and entered the local 300-year-old temple on 14 December. The inordinate delay in rebuilding a new entrance to the temple had invited the wrath of the public and a section of Dalits threatened to embrace other "tolerant" religion, specifically Buddhism.


 
 

HomeContact us Go back Print   |  Disclaimer |

 
 

© www.bharatjagran.com